best ice cream in alabama

Matt's Homemade Ice Cream in Gulf Shores, Alabama, was voted tops in the state by Yelp reviewers. We paid a visit and taste-tested the flavors. Here are our top 20 favorites.

The Inside Scoop On Alabama's Best Ice Cream Shop

Yelp named Matt’s Homemade Ice Cream in Gulf Shores, Alabama, the top ice cream shop in the state. And, as ice cream connoisseurs and local “insiders,” you might say we were treated to the inside scoop.

Matt of Matt's Homemade Alabama Ice CreamWe recently visited with Matt Lumpkin and his crew at their shop at Bayou Village in Gulf Shores, a shopping center anchored by the Original Oyster House restaurant and located at the intersection of Gulf Shores Parkway and Windmill Ridge Road.

Matt shared his story with us. Born and raised in nearby Fairhope, Matt’s first career was in chemical sales for a large paint manufacturer.

After tiring of his “road warrior” status, Matt revisited his lifelong dream of owning an ice cream and coffee shop.

Three years ago he opened his first store on Gulf Shores Parkway next to Flowers by the Shore florist to big crowds. In February 2016, he opened his second shop at Bayou Village.

In one busy summertime week, Matt told us his crew scooped 618 gallons of ice cream. The day before we visited, Matt’s served 1,702 people. Seems like an awful lot of the ice dreamy treat, but it’s not really surprising when you learn that Matt’s ice cream is crafted exclusively in nearby Mobile for his stores.

With flavors inspired by the tropical environment of the Gulf Coast plus a host of seasonal concoctions, Matt’s is known for flavors like Alabama Hot Chocolate (served year round), candy corn, king cake, moon pie, peppermint and more.

On the day we visited, we tried flavors like blueberry, Creole praline, glazed doughnut (Krispy Kreme, of course), banana pudding, seagull tracks and many more.

In a nod to the Original Oyster House, Matt’s also serves ice cream featuring the restaurant’s peanut butter and key lime pies. Oh, and the top selling specialty treat: brownie sundae, featuring brownies made by Matt’s mom. Yum!

Matt pulled out all the stops letting us taste to our hearts' content. I don’t think I’ve ever eaten that much ice cream in one fell swoop, and it was amazing (and a perfect way to cool off on a warm day in July).

Matt's BreezeFor “dessert,” we concluded our taste testing with Matt’s Breeze, a 16-ounce local favorite composed of two shots of espresso blended with homemade butter pecan ice cream and topped with whipped cream, chocolate powder, cinnamon powder and chocolate syrup.

Matt’s is also now serving his own proprietary blend of coffee roasted just for the shop. Be sure to stop by during your next Gulf Coast vacation.

Matt’s is open from 1-10 p.m., seven days a week. It is located just a couple of minutes south of the Meyer Vacation Rentals office in Gulf Shores.

Our Fave Top 20


20. Chocolate Peanut Butter
Chocolate Peanut ButterDouble trouble! This classic combo will make you feel like you are taking a bite out of a Reese’s cup.



19. Seagull Tracks
Seagull TracksFly high with this flavor. Enjoy the variety of flavors that goes in this ice cream – nuts, caramel, chocolate and more. It will keep your taste buds guessing what comes next.



18. Bubble Gum
Bubble GumBubble gum, bubble gum in my dish! This flavor is perfect for ice cream lovers of all ages, with yummy little bites size pieces of real bubble gum. In this flavor, you get two treats in one.


17. Strawberry
StrawberryStrawberry ice cream never tasted so good. Nothing beats a classic. You’ll enjoy the fresh taste of strawberries in this mix.



16. Toffee Crunch
Toffee CrunchCrunchy goodness is the way to describe this sweet treat. Indulge in the creamy blend of toffee and ice cream with bits of candy. A sensational flavor with every bite.



15. Green Mint Chip
Green Mint ChipThis minty treat is packed with yummy chocolate. It is the classic flavor of mint and chocolate, only better! Reminds us of Andes mints.



14. Glazed Doughnut
Glazed DoughnutNo sticky fingers with this decadent flavor. This cool treat makes you feel like you just pulled up to Krispy Kreme and indulged in of their freshly made glazed doughnuts.



13. Salted Caramel
Salted CaramelSweet yet a bit salty. That’s the best way to describe the salted caramel ice cream. The rich flavors of salted caramel and vanilla ice cream are the perfect treat for a hot day.


12. Blueberry Cheesecake
Blueberry CheesecakeThe blueberry cheesecake ice cream is a perfect treat to indulge in after a long day in the sun. Rich with the flavors of fresh blueberries and rich cheesecake, this ice cream flavor is a winner.


11. Birthday Cake
Birthday CakeTake a bite out of this fabulous flavor and it will make you feel like you are celebrating your birthday with a bang. This flavor has huge ribbons of real icing mixed in with its rich cake flavored ice cream.


10. Caramel Swirl
Caramel SwirlClassic caramel swirl! A ribbon of caramel winds throughout the rich creamy vanilla, creating a decadent flavor.



9. Matt’s Vanilla
Matt’s VanillaThis isn’t your grocery store vanilla ice cream. It’s so much sweeter. Matt’s use of Mexican vanilla means the flavor is both rich and sweet. This flavor tastes like it was just churned.


8. Cookies and Cream
Cookies and CreamThis classic got an upgrade. Enjoy giant chunks of Oreo cookie blended in with the creamy vanilla ice cream. A festival of flavor that’s both crunchy and creamy.



7. Cappa Crunch
Cappa CrunchDon’t burn your tongue on this cappuccino. This yummy cappuccino-flavored ice cream, blending both sweet and bitter, will cool you down on any hot summer day.



6. Blueberry
BlueberryForgot to pick up blueberries from the grocery? No problem. This blueberry-flavored ice cream will make your feel like you just picked a handful of fresh blueberries right off the bush.


5. Strawberry Cheesecake
Strawberry CheesecakeThis decadent flavor tastes as though you’re just sliced off a large piece of strawberry cheesecake. Churned into ice cream, the cheesecake is even tastier.



4. Alabama Hot Chocolate
Alabama Hot ChocolateIt’s hot outside, but it’s time for a hot chocolate. Alabama hot chocolate ice cream, that is. It’s a chocolate flavor that’s not overly sweet, and it’s a proprietary flavor and top seller for Matt’s Homemade Ice Cream.


3. Peach
PeachNothing speaks of summertime more than biting into a nice juicy peach. Well, that’s what you’ll think you did when you taste Matt’s peach-flavored ice cream. Tastes like summertime and is #3 choice.


2. Banana Pudding
Banana PuddingThis flavor will drive you bananas when you taste it! You won’t believe you are taking a bite of ice cream until you get a brain freeze from eating it too quickly. A scoop of this ice cream will take you right back to grandma’s banana pudding.


1. Creole Praline
Creole PralineRemember the creamy richness of the last praline you ate? Well, this creamy, nutty treat tastes just like that. Only better. It was our all-time favorite flavor.


More Beach Treats

Ice cream and the beach go hand in hand on the Gulf Coast. Visit Matt’s next time you are staying in an Orange Beach, Fort Morgan or Gulf Shores beach house or condo.
search houses search condos

Related Articles

Shopping In And Around Gulf Shores

Drop Anchor At Gulf Coast Area Shops

Take a break from the beach and browse the many shops and boutiques open in the Gulf Shores and Orange Beach area. You're bound to find something you love!

5 reasons why you can't miss Waterville USA

5 reasons why you can't miss Waterville USA

Ready to get wet and wild? Head over to Gulf Shores, Alabama for Waterville USA, one of the best waterparks in the Southeast! With slippery rides ranging from lazy rivers to exhilarating wave pools, you and the entire family will have quite the adventure.

Fun places for live music in the Gulf Shores area

Fun places for live music in the Gulf Shores area

Looking for a fun night out while enjoying your Gulf Shores area vacation? There are plenty of local eateries where you can enjoy food and drinks, but these three are among the best if you're looking for live music to top it all off.

Awesome pizza joints in Gulf Shores

Awesome pizza joints in Gulf Shores

Your getaway along Alabama's Gulf Coast will be filled with all-you-can-eat shrimp and oysters, and nearly bottomless supplies of fish. But for visitors who want something a little different, this bustling part of the South has a number of other options, including everyone's favorite: pizza!

There are plenty of shopping opportunities near Orange Beach rentals.

Shopping opportunities abound near Orange Beach rentals

There is a multitude of shopping opportunities near Orange Beach condo rentals. Whether you're looking for a classic souvenir, a quirky collectible or high-end clothes and jewelry, there's a store in Orange Beach that will have exactly what you need.

3 popular shrimp restaurants in Gulf Shores

3 popular shrimp restaurants in Gulf Shores

Eating fresh-caught Gulf shrimp is high on the to-do list for many visitors to Gulf Shores. Nearly all the seafood restaurant in the city serve fresh shrimp cooked every which way, so no matter where you go, you're find something a delicious to enjoy.

Newest Articles

Sample Fine Seafood at Orange Beach's Voyagers

There are a number of exquisite restaurants to be found near your Orange Beach rentals, yet few are as committed to freshness as Voyagers.

October 12, 2013 - Orange Beach | Restaurants to Visit

Head to Cobalt for fine dining in Orange Beach

Cobalt offers a fantastic view and a delicious menu for nights when you want to enjoy the best of Orange Beach area dining.

July 20, 2013 - Orange Beach | Restaurants to Visit

Find the best southern eats in Gulf Shores

Exploring your Gulf Shores house or condo is only half the fun. Don't forget to do some taste testing of southern cooking, too!

July 02, 2013 - Gulf Shores | Restaurants to Visit

Location

Gulf Shores Map

Upcoming Events

  • Oct 1
    5th Annual Alabama Festival of Flavor 2016
  • Oct 7
    The 13th annual John L. Borom Alabama Coastal BirdFest
  • Oct 8
    The 13th annual John L. Borom Alabama Coastal BirdFest
  • Oct 9
    The 13th annual John L. Borom Alabama Coastal BirdFest
  • Oct 13
    45th Annual National Shrimp Festival
  • Oct 14
    45th Annual National Shrimp Festival
  • Oct 15
    45th Annual National Shrimp Festival
  • Oct 16
    45th Annual National Shrimp Festival

Local Weather

weather icon 79º Conditions: Clear
Humidity: 44%
Wind: WNW 10 mph

Weather information provided by wunderground.com

Last Updated on September 30, 4:35 PM CDT

Latest Video